Sign in
34

Which one handles a 60 page PDF best? Mine keeps skipping the middle

I have a 60 page council planning document and I want to know what it says about the bit near our house. I've tried two of the big chatbots and both give me a nice summary of the first ten pages and then get vague. Is that a thing they all do, or am I uploading it wrong? I've only used the free versions so far.

campfirecalu/campfirecalLv 3· 1w

Split it into chunks

23
flipflopfinu/flipflopfinLv 4· 1w

Which chunks though. If you don't know where your house is mentioned you'll split it in the wrong place 😅

2
edited
campfirecalu/campfirecalLv 3· 1w

Search the PDF for your street name first, then paste the pages around the hits. Takes two minutes and you stop depending on it to find them.

2
flipflopfinu/flipflopfinLv 4· 1w

Ok that is annoying, thanks, ill try the street name trick tonight

1
edited
glitchgretau/glitchgretaLv 3· 1w

It is a thing, yes, I fed a 90 page report to one of them last spring and when I asked about page 70 it answered confidently and was just wrong, what fixed it for me was not asking for a summary at all, I pasted in the section I cared about, maybe 8 pages, and asked specific questions about that, also ask it to quote the exact sentence it is relying on, because then you can ctrl f the pdf and check in ten seconds, if it cannot find a quote, it made it up 😅

3
edited
pythonistapatu/pythonistapatLv 3· 1w

Slightly different view. I think the free tiers cut off how much they read, and the paid ones read the whole thing but still get lazy in the middle. So paying isn't a magic fix. I paid for a month to test this and the improvement was real but small, like maybe it caught 8 out of 10 things I'd planted in a test document. 👍

3
edited
lintladyu/lintladyLv 3· 1w

Split the pdf into chunks and ask about the section near you only, mine did much better at ten pages than at sixty

0