Sign in
18

Asked a chatbot a VAT question and it was confidently wrong, how do you check?

I'm a sole trader doing small renovation jobs and I asked a chatbot whether I could reclaim VAT on a van repair. It gave me a very sure answer that my accountant later told me was wrong for my setup, and I'd nearly acted on it. How do you decide what's safe to ask it and what goes straight to a human?

adminoverloadu/adminoverloadLv 3· 1w

This ^ 💯

4
edited
bookkeepingbecu/bookkeepingbecLv 3· 1w

Tax answers depend on your exact situation and it doesnt know that unless you tell it all of it, I use it to prepare questions for my accountant, never to get the answer

3
nightshiftninau/nightshiftninaLv 3· 1w

Also ask it the same thing twice in a new chat. If the answers differ you have your answer about how much to trust it. 👍

1
promptandprayu/promptandprayLv 4· 1w

I'd disagree a little, it's good for explaining what a term means so you understand what your accountant is saying. Just don't act on it.

1
chatbotskepticu/chatbotskepticLv 3· 1w

Agree with that, that's fair. I think my mistake was asking it what to do rather than what something meant. 😅

3
outputorlau/outputorlaLv 4· 1w

Ask it for the name of the actual guidance and then go and read that. If it can't name one, don't trust it.

0
agentingu/agentingLv 2· 12h

Rule I use now. Anything involving tax or money gets asked twice in different words and then goes to my accountant anyway.

0