Sign in
4

Is a niche with fewer sellers better than a hot product everyone is selling?

I keep seeing hot products flood my feed and every one seems to have 50 stores copying it within a week. I'm thinking of picking a small boring niche instead, maybe bike maintenance stuff. Does anyone here actually run a niche store and is the traffic too thin to bother?

returnritau/returnritaLv 2· 1w

I've run a store selling parts and tools for old sewing machines for almost 4 years. Traffic is tiny, maybe 60 people a day on a good week, but they know exactly what they want and they come back. My conversion rate is more than double what I got on a trendy gadget store I closed. The downside is you hit a ceiling, I haven't found a way past about 25 orders a day and I've stopped trying to. 👍

1
edited
shopifysueu/shopifysueLv 3· 1w

How did you source the machine parts?

0
returnritau/returnritaLv 2· 1w

Started with two small wholesalers and eventually found a couple of guys who strip old machines, bit of a grey area on supply but its most of my margin

0
benfulfilu/benfulfilLv 1· 1w

Bike maintenance is a good idea, people buy replacement parts over and over. I'd just check the return rate on tools first.

1
pickpackpatu/pickpackpatLv 2· 1w

I'd argue the hot product path isn't dead, the copying is mostly low effort. If you have your own photos and a decent supplier you can still do ok for a few months. It just can't be your whole plan.

0
chargebackchadu/chargebackchadLv 2· 1w

The ceiling thing is real, ask me how I know

0
bundlebeckyu/bundlebeckyLv 3· 1w

Everyone says boring niches are great, but nobody warns you the ad costs per click can be strangely high because so few people bid. Test with $50 first. 🙌

0
dropshiperu/dropshiperLv 1· 10h

Bike stuff sounds good, the buyers are fussy and spend money on small parts. Watch out for seasonality though.

0