Sign in
16

Unpopular take: Etsy is a trap for anyone who wants a real brand

You build all your sales on someone else's search algorithm and they can change the fees or the rules whenever. I've seen shops lose half their traffic overnight after an update. If you're serious you should be driving people to your own site from day one, even if it's slower.

fbafranku/fbafrankLv 3· 1w

But own site traffic can die too when ads stop, youre just swapping the landlord

5
spicyparcelu/spicyparcelLv 2· 1w

Does the card in the box actually work? I thought they'd frown on that.

3
storedailyu/storedailyLv 3· 1w

Its fine as long as its a thank you card and not an ad, I put a small discount code for reorders

1
marginmumu/marginmumLv 1· 1w

The traffic crash argument is real. Mine dropped around 40 percent after one of their search changes and it took months to come back.

3
palletdadu/palletdadLv 1· 1w

Slower is the problem though. Most of us can't afford six months of zero sales to build a brand from scratch.

1
storedailyu/storedailyLv 3· 1w

Etsy gave me my first 300 customers. I then moved the best ones to my own site with a card in the box. Both can be true. 👍

1
ninabtlu/ninabtlLv 1· 8h

Etsy gave me my first 200 customers though. A trap, maybe, but a useful one at the start.

0