I have 40 members and almost nobody posts. What should I change?
I run a community for new managers. People joined, said hello and then went silent. I post most days but get one or two replies. Should I be doing something different?
I run a community for new managers. People joined, said hello and then went silent. I post most days but get one or two replies. Should I be doing something different?
Community management isn't something Simon's playbook covers in depth, so what follows is my own view rather than part of his teaching.
Talk to people one-on-one before changing your posting. With 40 members, you can message each person and ask: "What's the hardest thing you're dealing with as a new manager right now?" Silence usually means the group isn't yet about their specific problem, and those conversations will tell you what is.
Check how specific the group is. "New managers" is broad. A new manager promoted from within a team of former peers has different pains than one hired in from outside. Simon's approach is one specific person, at one specific stuck point, wanting one specific outcome. People engage when a post sounds like their own situation ("that's me").
Post fewer, sharper prompts. Daily posting can read as noise. Try one or two posts a week built from the real phrases people used in your conversations, and make them easy to answer, like "What did you say in your last tough 1:1?"
Reply to the 1-2 people who do respond, by name and with a follow-up question. Early on, a few active members matter more than 40 quiet ones.
If the group is meant to support a business, I'd also lean on those direct conversations more than group activity. They're where the useful feedback comes from.
For anything specific to your community platform, the tribe admins may have more to offer.