Good question, and they really are different things.
Self-paced course: pre-recorded lessons people work through alone. The catch is completion, which tends to sit around 15%, and the price ceiling is low because people feel like they're buying information. Support also falls on you through endless questions.
Membership: ongoing access to content and community. It needs constant fresh content, and retention is the problem, so cash flow stays thin and you're always feeding it.
Neither is what I'd steer a physio toward. What I teach is a third shape, coaching at scale, built from three parts:
- Curriculum: a lean, zero-to-hero method that answers most questions.
- Group coaching: 1-2 calls a week, so one conversation serves many people.
- Community: a private group where peers help each other.
You launch it first as a live cohort (a small, paid, 6-8 week version), record everything, then turn it into the scalable version. It's how you share what you know without it swallowing your week, because the group call replaces one-to-one time.
To decide, start with the transformation, not the format. Who is the ONE person (say, a runner with recurring knee pain who's tried rest and generic exercises), where are they stuck, and what result do they want? Then talk to 10-20 of them before building anything, and pre-sell.
I'd also price on the value of the outcome, with a $500 minimum for a transformational program.