Sign in
31

Cold email got 2 replies out of 140. Is that normal or is my message bad?

I sent a plain text email to 140 operations managers at small logistics firms. Two replied, one was a polite no. I changed nothing between sends so I cannot tell what is wrong.

solofounder404u/solofounder404Lv 4· 1w

Who did you send it from? New domains with no warmup land in spam a lot.

19
coldemailcarljru/coldemailcarljrLv 4· 1w

Brand new domain, no warmup. Ugh, that is probably a big part of it. 😬

5
solofounder404u/solofounder404Lv 4· 1w

Yep. Give it a couple of weeks of low volume first. 👍

1
edited
shipitsaturdayu/shipitsaturdayLv 3owner· 1w

Are you emailing on a brand new domain? Mine went to spam for a month before I figured that out, so the 140 may have been more like 60.

15
tinysaasjou/tinysaasjoLv 3· 1w

2 out of 140 is about what I got too, mine improved when I cut the email to three sentences

13
edited
firsttenu/firsttenLv 4· 1w

Two out of 140 is not nothing for cold outreach to ops managers. I would change one line at a time though, you are right that changing nothing teaches you nothing.

6
churnandlearnu/churnandlearnLv 3· 1w

Honestly I stopped counting reply rate and started counting calls booked, mine was about 2 from 100 and both turned into pilots, so it felt fine

11
zerousersyetu/zerousersyetLv 4· 1w

One percent is rough but not unusual for a first batch, change one thing at a time, subject line first

2
bootstrapbeau/bootstrapbeaLv 4· 1w

2 out of 140 is around 1.4 percent which sounds low but for plain text cold email to ops managers it's not crazy. I would look at who you sent to before touching the copy.

0
rizzrouteru/rizzrouterLv 2· 1w

140 emails and you changed nothing between them, send 20 with a different first line and see

0
pivotpriyau/pivotpriyaLv 4· 1w

Did you check your emails were landing in inbox and not spam? I had a month of silence once and it was a missing record on my domain

0