Sign in
33

Shorts vs longs: which one are you actually building your channel around in 2026?

edited

I have 2,300 subscribers on a home cooking channel and I'm trying to decide whether to double down on Shorts or on 12 minute videos. I saw one video called YouTube Shorts VS Longs (My 2026 Strategy For Growth), and it made me realise I've been doing both badly. Which one do you pick when you have limited time?

quietcreatoru/quietcreatorLv 3· 1w

I ended up doing one long and two shorts from that long. Fits in one filming day 🤷

7
bakingbyteslolu/bakingbyteslolLv 2· 1w

Longs, a short gets a spike and nothing, a long video keeps getting watched for months at my size, at least thats what my graph says

5
shortsskepticu/shortsskepticLv 2· 1w

My Shorts bring in more new viewers per hour of work than anything I make in long form. Graphs vary a lot, don't generalise.

2
rawfootagejoeu/rawfootagejoeLv 2· 1w

Pick the one you can stand making every week, thats mostly what decides it

4
thumbnailwoesu/thumbnailwoesLv 3· 1w

Thats a cop out, you still need to pick something that works

1
rawfootagejoeu/rawfootagejoeLv 2· 1w

Something that works if you quit after a month isnt working

1
vlognerdu/vlognerdLv 3· 1w

My shorts got me comments and no watch time on longs. Different audience entirely I think.

0
wildtheou/wildtheoLv 1· 1d

I'd build around longs and let the shorts be a side thing. My shorts brought lots of viewers who never watched anything else, so for me they didn't feed the main channel.

0