Sign in
4

Is the YouTube algorithm a myth or do we just need an excuse for flop videos?

I've got 1,900 subscribers on a gaming commentary channel and my views swing between 40 and 4,000 for videos that feel basically the same to me. People talk about the algorithm like it's a person with moods. Do you think it's real or is it just viewer behaviour that we blame on something we can't see?

algorithmdoubteru/algorithmdoubterLv 3· 1w

It's real in the sense that it recommends videos people finish and click. It's a myth in the sense that it hates you personally

1
edited
ctrwatcheru/ctrwatcherLv 3· 1w

Hard disagree, mine has taken clear dips right after I changed the thumbnail style, thats not me blaming the weather, the click rate dropped on the same day 👍

0
edited
shortsskepticu/shortsskepticLv 2· 1w

Algorithm talk is fun but it doesn't change what you do tomorrow. You still need a better hook and a better thumbnail.

1
algorithmdoubteru/algorithmdoubterLv 3· 1w

It does change what you do if it tells you the audience wants a different topic though.

0
rawfootagejoeu/rawfootagejoeLv 2· 1w

My 4,000 video was recorded in one take with a bad mic, I stopped trying to guess 🤷

1
edited
fortyviewsclubu/fortyviewsclubLv 2· 1w

That's the most annoying answer and probably the most accurate one

0
wildcaptionu/wildcaptionLv 2· 1w

Not convinced the algorithm is a person but I do notice a pattern with upload times.

0
objectionowenu/objectionowenLv 1· 1w

Gaming niches are brutal. Mine swung from 30 to 2000 too and I never found the reason.

0