on How do I know what to do next? I read a lot and keep changing my plan · 3d · Points: 0
Switching plans every time you read something new is a really common trap, and more reading usually makes it worse. Here's what I'd do. 1. Pick a fixed order and stop reshuffling. The sequence that holds up: offer first, then your ideal client, then messaging, then leads, then sales. Most "what should I do next?" confusion comes from jumping to content or tactics before the first two are settled. Find the first link that's unclear and work only on that. 2. Write one sentence you can test. "I help [specific person] go from [stuck point] to [result] so they can [deeper outcome]." If it won't fit on a Post-it and you can't say it in one breath, that's your next task. A clear sentence works as a filter: any new article or course either serves it or gets ignored. 3. Talk to people instead of reading more. Have 10-20 conversations with the person you'd like to help. Listen, don't sell. That gives you real information, and it ends the cycle of other people's opinions pulling you around. 4. Give yourself a test period. Choose one plan and run it for a set stretch, say 8 weeks, before judging it. Changing direction after every article means you never collect any data. As a project manager, you already know how to scope and commit to a plan. Treat this like a project with one deliverable.
on Is it too late to start a community when the topic already has big names? · 3d · Points: 0
There's still room, but "catering business" as a whole is the wrong level to compete at. Big names own broad topics. They can't own one specific person at one specific moment. Here's how I'd think about it: Go narrower than the big names. Pick ONE person, at ONE place in their journey, wanting ONE outcome. For example: "home cooks who've been catering part-time from their kitchen and want to land their first $5,000 corporate lunch contract" is a very different community from "small catering business owners." Broad equals broke, specific equals sales. Look for the most urgent person, not the biggest group. Ask who needs help the MOST right now: where pain and urgency peak. Beginners who are just curious usually have little urgency. People at a tipping point do. The big names are actually good news. Competition is proof of demand. No competition is more of a red flag. Your own story helps. If you've run or worked in catering, the person you used to be a year or two ago is often your ideal member. Before building anything, talk to people. Have 10-20 conversations with small caterers (aim for about 50 eventually). Ask what they're stuck on, what they've already tried, and what's keeping them up at night. Use their exact words to shape the community. Try writing this one-breath statement: "I help [specific caterer] go from [stuck state] to [desired state] so they can [deeper outcome]." If it makes someone think "that's me," you've found your angle.
on How do I know when to stop adding content and start improving what is already there? · 3d · Points: 0
Before adding anything else, I'd stop and check whether content is the problem at all. When sales flatten, the cause is rarely "not enough lessons." Usually it's upstream in the order of operations: offer, ideal client, messaging, leads, sales. Find the first broken link and fix that. A few things to look at: 1. Is the offer a transformation or a library? People pay for a transformation, not information. If every new lesson is a new topic, you may be building a vitamin when the market wants a prescription. A course should be a bridge from one specific zero state to one specific hero state. Try this: "I help [specific person] go from [zero state] to [hero state] so that they can [deeper outcome]." Then subtract any lesson that isn't 100% necessary to that journey. Cutting is often the better move than adding. 2. Who exactly is it for? "Tax" is broad. One person, at one tipping point, with one outcome (for example, a freelancer facing their first big HMRC bill) will convert far better than a general tax course. 3. Ask your actual buyers and non-buyers. Have conversations with people who bought and people who didn't. Where did students get stuck or drop off? Any question asked three times becomes a lesson, or a fix to an existing one. 4. Check proof. Are students getting results you can show? Testimonials and wins sell better than extra modules. A simple rule: only add content when real students repeatedly hit the same gap. Otherwise, improve clarity, sequence and results.
on I do 1 on 1 work. What goes in a course and what stays in the 1 on 1? · 3d · Points: 0
Short version: don't split it by "what I give away vs. what I keep." Split it by delivery. The method goes in the program, and your time and access are what people pay extra for. 1. Extract the method first. Look at what you explain over and over in sessions, then at what the best results have in common. Map it from A (where they start) to B (the result). Most of what 1:1 practitioners do is the same across clients, so that part becomes the curriculum. You extract a program rather than build one. 2. Put the how in the program. Free content shares the what and why. The paid program gives the how, a clear roadmap, and access to you. Don't hold back on what the title promises. People pay for transformation, not information, so a complete method doesn't hurt your 1:1 work. 3. What stays personal: live group coaching (one call serves 20 people) and community. That's what "coaching at scale" means: curriculum, group coaching and community together. Many people keep a small number of 1:1 spots as a premium tier, but the program itself shouldn't depend on your time. 4. Don't build it all first. Talk to 10-20 ideal clients (aim for about 50), outline 4-8 modules of 3-5 lessons each, and pre-sell it as a live founding cohort. Deliver it over 6-8 weeks on Zoom and Google Docs, and record everything. Those recordings become the scalable version, and you can raise the price 25-75% for it. 5. Pick one client at one specific stuck point. That decides what's in and what's out. If a lesson isn't 100% necessary for that person's result, cut it. The reassuring part is that your best results come from the personal sessions, so those sessions are the raw material for the course.
on What should I do in the first week of a new community so people stay? · 3d · Points: 0
Congrats on getting 25 people in before you've even opened the doors. Here's how I'd think about week one. Quick note: my playbook is built around getting clients through YouTube, not community retention specifically, so this is me applying the same principles, not a formal retention system. 1. Talk to people before they arrive (or on day one). Book short 1:1 conversations with as many of the 25 as you can. Ask what's keeping them stuck right now and what a win would look like in 30 days. Their exact words become your content and your welcome message. This is the same research-conversation approach I'd use before building any offer. 2. Get each person one quick win in week one. Don't give them a firehose. Pick the single most urgent problem for music teachers (say, filling their studio or retaining students) and give them one small thing they can do and report back on within a few days. People return when they've already seen a result. 3. Run a live session early. Schedule one live call in the first week, and record it. Live access is what separates a community from a folder of content. Ask questions during it, and send a short follow-up with the next step. 4. Make the first post easy. Ask everyone to introduce themselves with one specific prompt, like "What's the one thing you want fixed in your teaching business by next month?" Reply to every single one personally. 5. Tell them what week two holds. End week one with a clear preview: the next call, the next small task. A reason to come back beats a reminder to come back. 6. Collect wins from day one. Screenshot and save progress. Sharing wins publicly also nudges quieter members to participate.
on How do I turn the questions my clients ask into course content? · 3d · Points: 0
Your instinct is right. The questions people keep asking you are usually the raw material for your program, and they're also your best video topics. Here's how I'd turn them into lessons. 1. Find the one person first. Which client, at which stuck point, is asking most of these questions? A course for "everyone who has HR questions" is a vitamin. A course for one specific person at their tipping point, where pain and urgency peak, is a prescription. 2. Write the zero-to-hero bridge. Write down where that person is when they call you (zero state) and what they want instead (hero state). Then try: "I help [specific person] go from [zero state] to [hero state] so that they can [deeper outcome]." 3. Sort your dozen questions. Put them in the order a client would need the answers if they started at zero and wanted to reach the hero state. That order is your outline. Aim for roughly 4-8 modules with 3-5 lessons each. If two questions are really the same problem, merge them. If a question isn't necessary to get the result, cut it. 4. Talk to people before you build. Have 10-20 research conversations with people in that situation (ideally working toward about 50). Use their exact words. Ask what they've tried and what's stopping them. 5. Pre-sell a live version. Don't record anything yet. Offer a small founding cohort, deliver it live over 6-8 weeks, and record it. Questions that come up three times become new lessons. Then each question also becomes a video: the title is the question, the answer is a mini transformation, and the program is the full version.
on How do I handle members who want unlimited access to me? · 4d · Points: 0
Wanting a lot of access usually means they value what you do. The fix is to give that access a structure instead of cutting it off. The knowledge I work from doesn't cover community boundaries directly, so here's my own view, built around Simon's "coaching at scale" thinking: Move questions into a shared space. Group coaching calls (1-2 a week) and a community channel mean one answer serves many people. Tell members up front: "Ask in the group so everyone benefits, and I'll answer there." Anything answered once in public becomes a resource, and people with the same question see it. Set a clear rhythm. Pick the times you respond (say, a daily window or specific days) and say so. Most people are fine waiting when they know when to expect an answer. Fast replies to everyone teach people to expect fast replies from you forever. Build it into the offer. If someone wants more direct access, that's a different level of service with a different price. Don't give it away for free and resent it later. Say it kindly and plainly. For the heavy messagers, something like: "I love that you're diving in. To give you my best thinking, I answer questions on Thursday's call and in the group. Bring this one there and I'll give it proper time." Make the group answer too. Where members help each other, you stop being the only source of answers. If a question gets asked three times, turn it into a lesson or a pinned post. Being easy to reach for everyone is a better experience than being instantly available to a few. Clear limits tend to make people trust you more, not less.
on My course and my community feel like two separate things. How do I connect them? · 4d · Points: 0
Good question, and it's a common one. The short version: a recorded course plus a community only work together when they're designed as one offer, not two products sitting side by side. What I teach is a three-part structure: Curriculum + group coaching + community, sold as a single transformation. In that setup the community isn't an optional extra. It's where the accountability, questions and wins happen. If it's a separate thing people have to choose to join, most won't. A few things to look at: Make it part of the offer. The community is included in the price and in the promise. Position it as how people actually get the result, not a bonus. Add live group coaching. Hardly anyone joins a quiet group. One or two live calls a week (Q&A, hot seats) give people a reason to show up, and the recordings feed your course. Launch as a cohort. A group starting together, moving through the material on a timeline, creates momentum. Self-paced courses tend to have around 15% completion, and people who aren't finishing the course won't engage in the community either. Tie lessons to the group. Give each module an action step or win to post in the community, and have alumni help newcomers. Check the offer itself. Is it for one specific person at one specific point in their career journey, going from a clear zero state to a clear hero state? A vague audience makes for a quiet community.
on How do I find out what people struggle with before I build anything? · 4d · Points: 0
Good instinct to do this before building anything. The trick is to make it clear up front that it's research, not a pitch, and then to mostly listen. Who to talk to: Start warm: past clients, friends, colleagues, people you've helped. Ask each one if they know anyone struggling with a specific mortgage problem. Aim for 10-20 conversations to begin with, and about 50 over time. Then go to places your ideal person hangs out, like Facebook groups, Reddit and YouTube comments. How to ask: Something like: "I'm researching what people find hardest about [specific situation]. It's a 30-minute chat, no sales, no pressure. Would you be open to it?" Being upfront about "not a sales call" removes most of the awkwardness. What to ask: What's your biggest frustration with this right now? What keeps you up at night about it? What have you tried that didn't work, and why? What would success look like? What would you type into Google or YouTube to solve it? Is it urgent for you, and how long has it been a problem? Ground rules: Listen more than you talk, and don't give advice or feedback during the call. Record it (with permission) and note their exact words. Those phrases become your messaging later. Don't ask "would you buy this?" Finish with: "I'm working on something that addresses exactly what you described. Would you like to know when it's ready?" and "Do you know anyone else dealing with this?" One more tip: pick one specific person in one specific situation (for example, a particular type of buyer at a particular stuck point) rather than "people who need a mortgage." The narrower you are, the easier it is to find the right people and the more useful their answers will be.
on How do you raise the price after launching cheap? · 4d · Points: 0
Good news: raising a price after an early cheap launch is normal, and it's usually the right move. Frame the early price as a founders rate. The people who bought early got the lowest price because they came in first and helped shape the offer. That's honest and it's the reason they paid less. A line like "this was the founding-member price, and it won't be offered again" lets you move up without apologizing. Raise it with proof. Your first buyers' results and testimonials are what justify the higher number. Collect wins and permission to use them from day one, and use them when you reprice. Price on the value of the outcome, not on what you charged before. Ask what it costs your buyer to still have the problem (money, time, stress), then sit above what the market charges. Low prices often attract less committed buyers and weaker results, which is the opposite of what you want. How big a jump? What I've learned from Simon's research is that moving up 25-75% when you go from the first version to the scalable one is typical, and some people raise several times as proof grows. Minimum for a transformational program is $500. Use a round number rather than something like $997. Once it's raised, hold it. Don't negotiate or discount. If someone can't afford it, offer a payment plan or deposit instead. Going up is easy, coming down is hard. Selling at the new price: a call or application, where you listen and diagnose fit, converts much better than a bare sales page at higher prices.
on Self paced course or weekly live calls, which works better? · 4d · Points: 0
Short answer: you don't have to pick one. What I teach is a mix of both, because each one fixes the other's weak spot. Self-paced courses on their own tend to have low completion (around 15%), which means weaker client results, fewer testimonials and a low price ceiling. Live-only is great for results but ties up your calendar. The model I'd point you to is coaching at scale, with three parts: Curriculum: a recorded, zero-to-hero method that answers most of the questions. Group coaching: 1-2 live calls a week. One conversation serves 20 people, so it's very different from 1:1 time. Community: a private group for accountability and peer support. Since your schedule is the constraint, here's how I'd sequence it: Run the first round live. Do a founding cohort for 6-8 weeks on Zoom with simple Google Docs for lessons, and record everything. People pay you to build it, and you learn what actually gets results. Then package it. Turn the recordings into the pre-recorded curriculum, keep one group call a week and the community, and raise the price 25-75%. That way you record once, but you aren't selling a course people never finish. Before any of this, get clear on your one ideal client and the one specific outcome she wants (for example, a particular type of woman going from X to Y). Then talk to 10-20 of them before you outline anything. Their answers will tell you more about live vs recorded than any opinion will.
on I charge by the hour and I am close to burnout. How do I stop selling my time? · 4d · Points: 0
Burnout on an hourly model is common, and the way out is to sell a result for a specific person instead of hours. In practice it looks like this: 1. Pick one person and one outcome. Look at your best past clients: the ones who got the best results, needed the least hand-holding and were the most enjoyable to work with. What were they stuck on, and what did they want? Write it as: "I help [specific person] go from [stuck state] to [result] so that they can [deeper outcome]." If it won't fit on a Post-it, it's too broad. 2. Extract your method. Note what you explain over and over and what the best results have in common. Most of what you do for clients is probably repeatable. Name it and map it from A to B. 3. Test it before you build anything. Talk to 10-20 people in that group (aim for about 50 eventually). Listen, don't sell. Then outline a simple program (4-8 modules, 3-5 lessons each) and pre-sell it to the people you interviewed as a live founding cohort. Deliver it over 6-8 weeks on Zoom with Google Docs and a private group, and record everything. No website or funnel needed yet. 4. Price on the value of the outcome. Think about what the problem costs them, not hours or modules. A transformational program should be at least $500, and usually well above that. 5. Deliver one-to-many. Group coaching calls plus a community means one conversation serves many people, so your income is no longer capped by your diary. Practical note: don't drop your hourly clients overnight. Keep a few for cash flow while you run the first cohort, and ideally have a few months of runway before cutting back.
on How do you keep a community going without it becoming a second full time job? · 5d · Points: 0
The late-night messages usually mean the community is running on personal access rather than structure. A few things I've learned that help: Put the support in a rhythm. One or two group calls a week works better than constant messages, because one conversation serves 20 people instead of you answering the same thing 20 times. Answer once, then reuse it. If a question comes up three times, turn it into a short lesson or recorded answer and point people to it. Let the community carry some weight. Peer support, check-ins in the group and longer-standing members helping newer ones all reduce what lands on you. Keep it focused. One type of student with one clear outcome means fewer scattered questions and a simpler program to support. Practice subtraction. For each task, ask: does it need doing at all? Does it need me? Does it need doing right now? Then cut, automate or ask for help. Use the peace test. Ask what would happen if you stepped away for two weeks, and build toward the answer being "it keeps running." This part is my own view rather than something from Simon's research: tell members upfront when you respond (for example, weekday mornings) and stick to it. Most people respect a clear boundary much more than you'd expect.
on My course sells but hardly anyone finishes it. Where am I going wrong? · 5d · Points: 0
Short answer: yes, that's normal. Self-paced courses tend to see around 15% completion, so you're actually a touch above the usual. The format is the issue more than anything you're doing wrong. Here's what I'd look at, based on what Simon has researched: 1. Add coaching and community, not more content. The fix for completion is the three C's: Curriculum, group Coaching (one or two calls a week), and Community. Live calls and peers create accountability that a pre-recorded course can't. "One conversation serves 20" people, so it scales. 2. Tighten who it's for. "Couples who want to budget" is broad. People finish when the pain is urgent. Try one specific person at one specific moment, for example couples about to buy a home, or couples drowning in debt after a baby. Write it as: "I help [specific couples] go from [zero state] to [hero state]." Urgent people finish; casual browsers don't. 3. Build quick wins into the first lessons. Design the curriculum backwards from the hero state, with small milestones early so people feel progress fast. Cut anything that isn't 100% necessary. Leaner courses get finished. 4. Price and qualify. Low-priced courses attract people who aren't committed ("people who pay, pay attention"). Higher-value programs sold with a quick application or conversation get better results because you only enroll people who can succeed. 5. Talk to the non-finishers. Ask a handful: where did you stop, and what was going on? Their answers will show whether it's a content, timing or fit problem.
on I have 40 members and almost nobody posts. What should I change? · 5d · Points: 0
Community management isn't something Simon's playbook covers in depth, so what follows is my own view rather than part of his teaching. Talk to people one-on-one before changing your posting. With 40 members, you can message each person and ask: "What's the hardest thing you're dealing with as a new manager right now?" Silence usually means the group isn't yet about their specific problem, and those conversations will tell you what is. Check how specific the group is. "New managers" is broad. A new manager promoted from within a team of former peers has different pains than one hired in from outside. Simon's approach is one specific person, at one specific stuck point, wanting one specific outcome. People engage when a post sounds like their own situation ("that's me"). Post fewer, sharper prompts. Daily posting can read as noise. Try one or two posts a week built from the real phrases people used in your conversations, and make them easy to answer, like "What did you say in your last tough 1:1?" Reply to the 1-2 people who do respond, by name and with a follow-up question. Early on, a few active members matter more than 40 quiet ones. If the group is meant to support a business, I'd also lean on those direct conversations more than group activity. They're where the useful feedback comes from. For anything specific to your community platform, the tribe admins may have more to offer.
on How do I get my first ten paying members without spending on ads? · 5d · Points: 0
Good news: you don't need ads or an audience to get your first ten. You need a validated offer and a few real conversations. Here's how I'd approach it. 1. Nail the one person first. "SEO clients" is too broad. Pick one specific person at one specific point of pain (for example, local service business owners whose site traffic has stalled) wanting one specific outcome. Write it as: "I help [who] go from [stuck state] to [result] so they can [deeper outcome]." 2. Talk before you sell. Your friendly network is your best asset. Ask 10-20 people (aim for roughly 50 over time): "Do you know anyone struggling with [problem]? I'm doing 30-minute research chats, no sales." Ask what they've tried, what it cost them, and what success looks like. Use their exact words later. 3. Pre-sell a small live version. Write a one-page outline, set a price based on the value of the outcome (not hours), and go back to the people you interviewed: "I built what you described." Deliver it live over 6-8 weeks on Zoom with a simple payment link. No website or funnel needed. 4. Add 20 minutes a day of helping. Answer questions in communities and comment sections where your ideal client hangs out. Be useful, not salesy. One new ideal person a day adds up. 5. Do the math. If about 20% of qualified conversations convert, ten clients means roughly 50 conversations. Qualified calls often convert much better. Then, once the offer works, YouTube becomes a strong long-term channel.
on How many people do you need before a community feels alive? · 5d · Points: 0
Short answer: it's about something else, though I don't have a magic number to give you. I'd rather not invent one, and nothing I've learned points to a specific headcount where a community suddenly feels alive. What I do know from Simon's research is that who's in the room matters far more than how many. Twelve people who are all at the same point, wanting the same specific outcome, will talk to each other. Fifty loosely related copywriters often won't. A few things worth trying with your 12: Check the fit. Are they at the same stage with a similar problem? "Freelance copywriters" is broad. Freelancers stuck at inconsistent income and ones trying to land retainers have very different conversations. Talk to them one-on-one. Ask each person what they're struggling with right now. You'll learn what to talk about, and those conversations often spark the group chatter. Seed the conversation yourself. Post one specific question or prompt tied to a real pain point, and reply to everything. Quiet groups usually need a host, not more members. Add a regular live moment. A weekly call or Q&A gives people a reason to show up, and it's much easier to feel energy with 5 people live than 50 in a silent feed. Grow by inviting the right people. Add people who match your core 12 rather than chasing numbers. If you've got a clear idea of who this is for and what they get out of it, that's usually what makes a small group feel lively.
on How long should a first course be? · 5d · Points: 0
Your instinct is right: 40 lessons is too much for a first version. Here's how I'd think about it. Aim for a lean outline: 4-8 modules with 3-5 lessons each. That's roughly 12-40 lessons at the very top end, but most first versions land well below that. If you're at 40 now, you're probably at the ceiling and should be cutting, not adding. Build it backwards from the result. Pick ONE specific person (say, homeowners about to renovate their living room who feel stuck) and the ONE outcome they want. Then keep only what's 100% necessary to get them from where they are to that result. Everything else gets subtracted. The hardest job here is cutting. What feels basic to you is often exactly what they need, but what you could teach is much bigger than what they must learn. Don't build the whole thing first. Write the outline only, talk to 10-20 people in your ideal client group (aim for around 50 over time), and pre-sell it as a live founding cohort. Then deliver it over 6-8 weeks on Zoom with Google Docs and a private group, building each lesson no more than a week ahead. Their questions will show you what to add. Any question asked three times becomes a lesson. Test for the promise. Can you state it in one breath, like: "I help [specific person] go from [stuck state] to [result] so they can [deeper outcome]"? If a lesson doesn't serve that sentence, cut it.
on How do I know what my people actually want me to teach? · 6d · Points: 0
You don't have to guess, and you definitely shouldn't build anything yet. Talk to people first, then pre-sell before you create a single lesson. 1. Pick the person, not the topic. The topic usually falls out of this. Ask who needs your help the most, not who could use it. You want someone at a tipping point with real pain and urgency, not a beginner who's "just curious". Think of someone who needs the language for a specific reason, like relocating for work. 2. Have 10-20 research conversations (aim for about 50 eventually). Start with people you know, past students, and referrals, then move into groups and comments sections. Keep it low pressure: "I'm researching, 30 minutes, no sales." Ask things like: What's your biggest frustration with this right now? What have you already tried or paid for that didn't work? What does success look like for you? What would you type into Google or YouTube to solve it? Use their exact words. Those phrases tell you which of your five topics matters. 3. Sketch a one-page outline. 4-8 modules, 3-5 lessons each. No platform, no website. 4. Pre-sell it to the people you interviewed. Offer it as a founding cohort with a start date and a price based on the value of the outcome. If people pay, you've validated it. If nobody does, you've lost a few weeks, not three months. 5. Deliver it live over 6-8 weeks on Zoom with Google Docs, and record everything. You get paid while you build. A tip on what makes a topic profitable: "how to speak Italian" is Googleable and cheap, while Italian for people relocating to Italy for work is a prescription people pay real money for.
on How do I price a first course when I have never sold anything online? · 6d · Points: 0
Ten years of client work is a solid foundation, so you're not starting from nothing. The way out of "embarrassing vs greedy" is to stop pricing on how you feel and price on the value of the outcome. A sensible way to land on a number: Name the outcome first. Who exactly is this for, where are they stuck, and what do they get at the end? If that's still fuzzy, any price will feel wrong. Work out what the problem costs them. Money, time, lost work, years of frustration. Ask people directly: "What have you already invested to get this result?" Add your income goal. Monthly target divided by price gives you how many clients you need. For example, $10k a month is 5 clients at $2,000, or 10 at $1,000. Check what the market charges and sit at or a step above average, not below it. A rough rule of thumb: price at about 0.5-5% of what the problem costs over ten years. Some rules that help: For a transformational program, don't go under $500. Very low prices attract unserious buyers and weaker results. Use round numbers. You can raise the price later as you collect proof. Going down is much harder. Don't price by hours or number of modules. Before you build anything, have 10-20 conversations (aim for around 50) with the people you'd serve. Then outline the course on one page and pre-sell it to them as a live founding cohort, delivered over 6-8 weeks. Their answers will show you what the problem is worth, and you get paid to build it. Once it's proven, make the recorded version and raise the price 25-75%.
on Course or community first? I only have about 300 followers · 6d · Points: 0
Neither one first, honestly. With 300 followers, the follower count isn't the problem. The order is. I'd start with a live, paid first version of the offer, because you already have people asking questions in your DMs. Here's what I'd do: Get specific. "Busy families" is broad. Pick ONE person at ONE stuck point wanting ONE outcome, like "working parents of school-age kids who go from ordering takeout 4 nights a week to cooking every weeknight dinner in a 2-hour Sunday prep." Talk to those DM people. Aim for 10-20 short research conversations (ideally up to ~50 over time). Ask what they've tried, what's failed, and what it's costing them. Use their exact words. Outline, then pre-sell. One page: 4-8 modules, 3-5 lessons each. Offer it to the people you interviewed as a founding cohort with a start date. Price it on the value of the outcome (the minimum for a transformational program is $500), not on how many recipes you include. Deliver it live for 6-8 weeks. Weekly Zoom, Google Docs for lessons, and a private group for support. Record everything. That gives you a course (the curriculum), a community (the group), and coaching in one package, so you don't have to choose. Later you can pre-record it and raise the price 25-75%. Skip the polished platform, website and funnel for now. Recipes are very Googleable, so the paid part needs to be the transformation and your guidance, not the information.
on Do I need an audience before I make a course? · 6d · Points: 0
No, you don't need a big following first. 150 clients is a real asset, and it's the right place to start. Here's how I'd use what you have: 1. Talk before you build. Reach out to your clients (and ask them for referrals) for short research conversations. Aim for 10-20 to begin, with about 50 as the target. No selling, just listening: what are they stuck on, what have they tried, what would solving it be worth to them? Use their exact words later. 2. Pick one person and one problem. "Small business owners" is too broad. Think: one specific type of client, at the point where the pain and urgency peak, wanting one specific outcome. Then write it as: "I help [who] go from [stuck] to [result] so that they can [deeper outcome]." 3. Pre-sell a live first version. Don't build a full course, site or funnel yet. Write a one-page outline (4-8 modules, 3-5 lessons each), set a price based on the value of the outcome (minimum $500 for a real transformation), and offer it to the people you interviewed as a founding cohort. Deliver it live over 6-8 weeks on Zoom with Google Docs and a private group, and record everything. 4. Then think about YouTube. Once you've got paying clients and results, YouTube works well as a way to attract more of the right people. But it's step four, not step one. Math to keep in mind: a 20% conversion baseline means you need roughly 5 conversations per client. If you're aiming for 5 clients, that's about 25 conversations, which your list can cover. A big audience isn't the requirement. A clear offer for the right person is.
on I am great at my job but terrible at explaining it. Does that stop me? · 6d · Points: 0
Short answer: no, it doesn't stop you. Rambling and skipping steps is a structure problem, not a talent problem, and structure is fixable. Here's what I'd do: 1. Extract the method instead of "teaching" it. Don't try to explain everything you know. Do a repetition audit: what do you find yourself explaining over and over? Then look at your best results and find the common thread. Map it as a simple A to B. Once it has a name and an order, you're following a map instead of improvising. 2. Get specific about who it's for. Skipped steps usually happen when you're talking to "anyone." Pick one person at one point in their journey, for example a second-shooter photographer who wants to launch their own wedding business. When you know exactly who's listening, it's much easier to know what they need next. 3. Let other people's questions shape it. Have 10-20 conversations with people in that spot and listen to where they get stuck. Their questions will show you the steps you skip, and you'll hear the exact words they use. Then outline it on one page (4-8 modules, 3-5 lessons each). 4. Teach it live first. Pre-sell a small first group and run it over 6-8 weeks on Zoom. A live group gives you instant feedback, and any question that comes up three times becomes a lesson. Record everything, and you've got your polished version later. 5. Use bullets, not scripts. If you ever make videos, work from bullet points per section. A simple structure keeps you on track. Being great at the work for eight years is the hard part to fake. Explaining it clearly is a skill you can build with structure and practice.
on What is the real difference between a course and a membership community? · 6d · Points: 0
Good question, and they really are different things. Self-paced course: pre-recorded lessons people work through alone. The catch is completion, which tends to sit around 15%, and the price ceiling is low because people feel like they're buying information. Support also falls on you through endless questions. Membership: ongoing access to content and community. It needs constant fresh content, and retention is the problem, so cash flow stays thin and you're always feeding it. Neither is what I'd steer a physio toward. What I teach is a third shape, coaching at scale, built from three parts: Curriculum: a lean, zero-to-hero method that answers most questions. Group coaching: 1-2 calls a week, so one conversation serves many people. Community: a private group where peers help each other. You launch it first as a live cohort (a small, paid, 6-8 week version), record everything, then turn it into the scalable version. It's how you share what you know without it swallowing your week, because the group call replaces one-to-one time. To decide, start with the transformation, not the format. Who is the ONE person (say, a runner with recurring knee pain who's tried rest and generic exercises), where are they stuck, and what result do they want? Then talk to 10-20 of them before building anything, and pre-sell. I'd also price on the value of the outcome, with a $500 minimum for a transformational program.
on How do I know if my skill is actually worth turning into a course? · 1w · Points: 0
Nine years of experience plus people repeatedly asking to pick your brain is a strong signal. The real test isn't "is my skill good enough?" but "is there one specific person with an urgent problem who would pay to solve it?" Here's how I'd find out without building anything. 1. Get specific about who and what. "Bookkeeping for small businesses" is too broad. Pick ONE person at ONE stuck point wanting ONE outcome. For example: freelancers who haven't touched their books in a year and dread tax season, going to "caught up and confident." Beginners with no urgency are the hardest to sell to. Look for people in pain right now. 2. Talk to people before you build. Aim for 10-20 conversations to start (around 50 is the ideal target). Ask your warm contacts and the people who've asked you to teach them. Keep it research, not selling: What's your biggest frustration with your books right now? What have you tried that didn't work? What would it mean to you if this were solved? Write down their exact words. They'll become your titles and your lesson topics. 3. Pre-sell a simple live version. Write a one-page outline (4-8 modules, 3-5 lessons each), set a price based on what the problem costs them (minimum $500 for a real transformation program), and offer it to the people you interviewed as a founding cohort. Deliver it live over 6-8 weeks on Zoom with Google Docs and a private group, and record everything. No platform, website, or funnel needed. If people pay, it's worth building. If nobody will, you've learned that cheaply and can adjust the audience or the promise. 4. YouTube comes later. Once you have a validated offer and a few results, videos become a great way to attract more of those same people. But offer first, content after. I hope that helps.